Criminal Justice Review https://cjreview.com/ Because Research Matters. Mon, 13 Nov 2023 00:55:08 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.6.2 218717480 America’s Most Dangerous Cities, and Their Parties https://cjreview.com/2023/11/13/americas-most-dangerous-cities-and-their-parties/ https://cjreview.com/2023/11/13/americas-most-dangerous-cities-and-their-parties/#respond Mon, 13 Nov 2023 00:53:55 +0000 https://cjreview.com/?p=90 Original Post: https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/crime/fbi-data-reveals-america-s-35-most-dangerous-cities/ss-AA1jNRyN?ocid=hpmsn&cvid=cd65169a243242cb8a96532434e51f74&ei=61#image=3 MSN recently made a post titled, “FBI Data Reveals America’s 35 Most Dangerous Cities.” This made for an interesting opportunity to review the data by means of party affiliation, as often there is a debate on whether or not Democrat or Republican controlled cities are safer. Without commentary, below are the five […]

The post America’s Most Dangerous Cities, and Their Parties appeared first on Criminal Justice Review.

]]>
Original Post: https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/crime/fbi-data-reveals-america-s-35-most-dangerous-cities/ss-AA1jNRyN?ocid=hpmsn&cvid=cd65169a243242cb8a96532434e51f74&ei=61#image=3

MSN recently made a post titled, “FBI Data Reveals America’s 35 Most Dangerous Cities.” This made for an interesting opportunity to review the data by means of party affiliation, as often there is a debate on whether or not Democrat or Republican controlled cities are safer. Without commentary, below are the five most dangerous cities as noted by MSN, and their respective Mayors (accompanied by party affiliation).

  1. Memphis, Tennessee.
    Mayor: Jim Strickland, Democrat

2. Detroit, Michigan.
Mayor: Mike Duggan, Democrat

3. Little Rock, Arkansas.
Mayor: Frank Scott Jr., Democrat

4. Pueblo, Colorado.
Mayor: Nick Gradisar, Democrat

5. Tacoma, Washington.
Mayor: Victoria Woodards, Democrat

For reference, the first city with a Republican Mayor came in on the list at #15, referencing Mayor Kevin Lincoln in Stockton, CA. Technically #10, Springfield, Missouri, does not have a Democrat as Mayor, but only because the office is officially non-partisan.

The post America’s Most Dangerous Cities, and Their Parties appeared first on Criminal Justice Review.

]]>
https://cjreview.com/2023/11/13/americas-most-dangerous-cities-and-their-parties/feed/ 0 90
The Myth of “High Capacity” Gun Magazines https://cjreview.com/2023/11/13/the-myth-of-high-capacity-gun-magazines/ https://cjreview.com/2023/11/13/the-myth-of-high-capacity-gun-magazines/#respond Mon, 13 Nov 2023 00:33:56 +0000 https://cjreview.com/?p=25 Politicians adore the term, “high capacity magazine,” in references to guns. President Biden has made it a favorite when advocating for “gun control” and he blames the ills of weapon-related deaths on such accessories. It is important, however, that despite the rhetoric, people understand what this term means, and how it is being misused. “High […]

The post The Myth of “High Capacity” Gun Magazines appeared first on Criminal Justice Review.

]]>

Politicians adore the term, “high capacity magazine,” in references to guns. President Biden has made it a favorite when advocating for “gun control” and he blames the ills of weapon-related deaths on such accessories. It is important, however, that despite the rhetoric, people understand what this term means, and how it is being misused.

“High capacity” would logically refer to something excessive from the norm. Generally, politicians advocating for bans of such items claim this includes any firearm magazine capable of holding more than 10 rounds of ammunition (some states, such as Colorado, have set this limit at 15 rounds). One should ask, is this appropriate? The clear answer is no. More than 10 rounds of ammunition does not logically mean these magazines are “high capacity.”

In the 1960s, the introduction of civilian M16 variants came standard with a 20-round magazine. It was only a few short years later the United States Army set a standard of 30-round magazines accompanying said rifles. In 1980, NATO–through STAGNAG–adopted the 30-round magazine as a standard, as well. Thus, for roughly 60 years, magazines of more than 20 rounds have been normal in the world’s most popular rifles, and for over 40 years, the 30 round standard has been the norm.

Regarding pistols, the most famous of all is the Glock 17, designed by Gaston Glock. That pistol, introduced in 1982 and having since become a stalwart in both civilian and law enforcement circles, has 17 rounds and has since its inception. That is over 40 years of a 17 round capacity, with more than five million of these models sold (most other full size Glocks also carry similar amounts of ammunition, meaning more than 10 million exist).

Additionally, the Beretta M9/92SF, made famous by its use in the United States Army, has also come standard with 15-round magazines since the model’s adoption in 1990.

Under any consideration, there is no fair basis for referring to magazines with over 10 rounds of capacity as “high capacity.” It is irrational, and irresponsible, for politicians to adopt such terms. One could find it reasonable to refer to pistol magazines of more than 17 rounds, and rifle magazines over 30 rounds, as “high capacity,” but below those numbers is nothing more than made up political hyperbole.

The post The Myth of “High Capacity” Gun Magazines appeared first on Criminal Justice Review.

]]>
https://cjreview.com/2023/11/13/the-myth-of-high-capacity-gun-magazines/feed/ 0 25
St. Louis Mayor Tishaura Jones Using Tragedy for Political Gain https://cjreview.com/2023/06/19/st-louis-mayor-tishaura-jones-using-tragedy-for-political-gain/ https://cjreview.com/2023/06/19/st-louis-mayor-tishaura-jones-using-tragedy-for-political-gain/#respond Mon, 19 Jun 2023 13:31:06 +0000 https://cjreview.com/?p=59 Source: https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/crime/1-dead-10-injured-in-shooting-at-party-in-st-louis-office-building-police/ar-AA1cID7o?ocid=hpmsn&cvid=5468e031a9794a0ca7721750e7b14a21&ei=18 Mayor Jones responds to the tragedy in St. Louis and blames it on “lax gun laws.” She neglects, naturally, the myriad of crime being committed right in front of her. Let us break this incident down: Rather than focus on the existing laws of Missouri, Mayor Jones uses the death of a young […]

The post St. Louis Mayor Tishaura Jones Using Tragedy for Political Gain appeared first on Criminal Justice Review.

]]>
Source: https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/crime/1-dead-10-injured-in-shooting-at-party-in-st-louis-office-building-police/ar-AA1cID7o?ocid=hpmsn&cvid=5468e031a9794a0ca7721750e7b14a21&ei=18

Mayor Jones responds to the tragedy in St. Louis and blames it on “lax gun laws.” She neglects, naturally, the myriad of crime being committed right in front of her. Let us break this incident down:

  1. The shooter is 17. It was illegal for him to have a gun. He did not care. The fact that those 19 and over can carry a concealed firearm is completely irrelevant.
  2. It is illegal to shoot someone in almost every case. The shooter did not care.
  3. It sounds, although not confirmed, that the party where this incident happened was a social media-influenced gathering that involved an office building being burglarized.

Rather than focus on the existing laws of Missouri, Mayor Jones uses the death of a young person to air grievances with laws she does not agree with. Absolutely shameful.

The post St. Louis Mayor Tishaura Jones Using Tragedy for Political Gain appeared first on Criminal Justice Review.

]]>
https://cjreview.com/2023/06/19/st-louis-mayor-tishaura-jones-using-tragedy-for-political-gain/feed/ 0 59
Traffic Stop Recovers Stolen Gun https://cjreview.com/2023/05/27/traffic-stop-recovers-stolen-gun/ https://cjreview.com/2023/05/27/traffic-stop-recovers-stolen-gun/#respond Sat, 27 May 2023 23:43:54 +0000 https://cjreview.com/?p=56 It is interesting that something so common of an occurrence would find its way to MSN, but it is worth pointing out all the same out of principle. Each year in Washington state, legislators seem bent on taking away police powers to enforce traffic laws. They ignore research showing how traffic stops keep roads safer […]

The post Traffic Stop Recovers Stolen Gun appeared first on Criminal Justice Review.

]]>
It is interesting that something so common of an occurrence would find its way to MSN, but it is worth pointing out all the same out of principle. Each year in Washington state, legislators seem bent on taking away police powers to enforce traffic laws. They ignore research showing how traffic stops keep roads safer and how traffic stops in general can contribute to lower overall crime. They, too, ignore stories like this, showing how simple traffic stops can recover stolen firearms and bring into custody felons in possession of those firearms. Now, whether this suspect ever gets charged as a felon in possession of a (stolen) firearm… that’s another story.

In any case, good work, Seattle PD.

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/crime/seattle-police-recover-stolen-gun-during-traffic-stop/ar-AA1bMjyG?ocid=hpmsn&cvid=1f8660ab74fa4286af4f043b28e148c4&ei=112

The post Traffic Stop Recovers Stolen Gun appeared first on Criminal Justice Review.

]]>
https://cjreview.com/2023/05/27/traffic-stop-recovers-stolen-gun/feed/ 0 56
The Ineffectiveness of Assault Weapon Bans in Reducing Violent Crime https://cjreview.com/2023/05/24/the-ineffectiveness-of-assault-weapon-bans-in-reducing-violent-crime/ https://cjreview.com/2023/05/24/the-ineffectiveness-of-assault-weapon-bans-in-reducing-violent-crime/#respond Wed, 24 May 2023 09:17:18 +0000 https://cjreview.com/?p=53 Now that Washington’s “assault weapon” ban is in place, a lot of questions are swirling around as to whether or not this will actually help reduce violent crime. It would be easy to think that the talking heads and politicians that advocated for such a ban would be on solid footing before proposing such monumental […]

The post The Ineffectiveness of Assault Weapon Bans in Reducing Violent Crime appeared first on Criminal Justice Review.

]]>
Now that Washington’s “assault weapon” ban is in place, a lot of questions are swirling around as to whether or not this will actually help reduce violent crime. It would be easy to think that the talking heads and politicians that advocated for such a ban would be on solid footing before proposing such monumental legislation, given that they are entrusted with preserving the rights and freedoms of the people they serve. That is not, however, the case. The ban in Washington, as in every state that has one, is one with shaky evidence to support it (at best), and is of highly questionable constitutionality. Let us take a look at some actual data involving this topic, since the politicians who created, and supported, the bill apparently did not.

In recent years, the topic of gun control has sparked intense debates, with proponents and opponents fiercely advocating their respective positions. One aspect that frequently emerges from these discussions is the effectiveness of assault weapon bans in curbing violent crime. While proponents argue that such bans are necessary to enhance public safety, a closer examination reveals that they often fail to achieve their intended purpose. In brief, we will delve into the reasons why assault weapon bans lack effectiveness in reducing violent crime.

  1. Defining Assault Weapons: “Assault” is a verb. There are no “assault weapons.” What a human does with a weapon–whether a gun or a fork–can be an assault. The very term “assault weapon” is hyperbole and intended to stoke political ire. Similarly, the catch phrase “weapons of war” that often gets thrown out around guns of the AR-platform (that’s Armalite Rifle, not Assault Rifle, despite what fearmongers tell you) is equally as heinous. No war has been fought with AR-15 rifles. If one had been, it would be very short, as the AR-15 is not a platform suitable to make an army a contender in a serious conflict.
  2. Low Prevalence and Use in Crimes: Contrary to popular belief, assault weapons account for a small fraction of overall gun violence. The vast majority of crimes are committed using stolen or otherwise illegally acquired handguns, not assault rifles. According to the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), rifles of any kind, including those deemed assault weapons, were involved in less than 3% of homicides in recent years. This data challenges the assumption that banning assault weapons will have a significant impact on reducing violent crime rates.
  3. Existing Weapons Still Pose a Threat: Even if assault weapon bans were to be implemented, it would not eradicate the already-existing firearms in circulation. Millions of legally-owned firearms, including assault weapons, are already in the possession of law-abiding citizens. Criminals who intend to commit acts of violence can easily adapt and find alternative means to carry out their plans, such as utilizing other firearms or resorting to illegal channels to acquire prohibited weapons. Therefore, the focus should be on addressing the root causes of violence and finding comprehensive solutions that address all types of firearms rather than singling out a specific category.
  4. Misdirected Resources: Implementing and enforcing assault weapon bans require considerable resources, both financial and administrative. These resources could be better allocated towards initiatives that have a more significant impact on public safety, such as improved mental health services, community policing, and early intervention programs. By concentrating efforts on measures that address the complex underlying factors contributing to violence, we can foster a safer society for everyone.
  5. Second Amendment Considerations: The Second Amendment of the United States Constitution guarantees the right of citizens to bear arms. While this right is subject to reasonable regulations, any restrictions must be carefully balanced with individual freedoms. Implementing sweeping assault weapon bans raises constitutional concerns which have already had mixed results in court (even pre-Bruen) and face significant opposition from those who value their right to self-defense. Striking a balance that respects both public safety and individual liberties is paramount.

Looking at existing research, one of the earliest reviews of the federal ban previously in place in America (Department of Justice, Updated Assessment of the Federal Assault Weapons Ban: Impacts on Gun Markets and Gun Violence, 1994-2003) showed it to be inconclusive in reducing violent crime, specifically pointing out the low prevalence of guns deemed “assault weapons” being used in shootings in the first place.

While the desire to reduce violent crime is admirable, it is crucial to critically evaluate the effectiveness of proposed solutions. Assault weapon bans, despite their widespread support, have shown limited effectiveness in curbing violent crime. By examining the low prevalence of assault weapons in criminal activity, the persistence of existing firearms, the misdirection of resources, and the need to respect constitutional rights, it becomes evident that alternative approaches to reducing violence warrant more attention. It is imperative to focus on evidence-based strategies that address the root causes of violence and foster a comprehensive approach to public safety.

The post The Ineffectiveness of Assault Weapon Bans in Reducing Violent Crime appeared first on Criminal Justice Review.

]]>
https://cjreview.com/2023/05/24/the-ineffectiveness-of-assault-weapon-bans-in-reducing-violent-crime/feed/ 0 53
From Salon’s ‘Confronting the gun lobby’s biggest myth’ https://cjreview.com/2023/05/12/from-salons-confronting-the-gun-lobbys-biggest-myth/ https://cjreview.com/2023/05/12/from-salons-confronting-the-gun-lobbys-biggest-myth/#respond Fri, 12 May 2023 03:16:52 +0000 https://cjreview.com/?p=36 https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/opinion/confronting-the-gun-lobby-s-biggest-myth/ar-AA1b2CbH?ocid=hpmsn&cvid=2a7f92fe1cf04913813ceb7e9877ef5f&ei=17 Writer Nina Vinik aims for low-hanging fruit in the linked piece. Although much can be countered within her article, the premise is based on her statement of the following: ‘study after study has shown that homes with guns have more gun violence.’ Interestingly, study after study also shows that people harmed by automobiles are […]

The post From Salon’s ‘Confronting the gun lobby’s biggest myth’ appeared first on Criminal Justice Review.

]]>
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/opinion/confronting-the-gun-lobby-s-biggest-myth/ar-AA1b2CbH?ocid=hpmsn&cvid=2a7f92fe1cf04913813ceb7e9877ef5f&ei=17

Writer Nina Vinik aims for low-hanging fruit in the linked piece. Although much can be countered within her article, the premise is based on her statement of the following:

‘study after study has shown that homes with guns have more gun violence.’

Interestingly, study after study also shows that people harmed by automobiles are those who have automobiles, and those who develop smoking-induced lung cancer happen to smoke. Similarly, studies show that people who eat more are more often overweight, and homes with pools have more drownings.

In short, the argument has no actual merit, as it can be made about any product. Rather than focusing on real research–which clearly shows most gun crime is committed by people who break the law to acquire a gun–Vinik demonizes even law-abiding gun owners. It is unfortunate, but common amongst those who advocate for gun control that is more about control than it is the gun.

The post From Salon’s ‘Confronting the gun lobby’s biggest myth’ appeared first on Criminal Justice Review.

]]>
https://cjreview.com/2023/05/12/from-salons-confronting-the-gun-lobbys-biggest-myth/feed/ 0 36
Washington primed to ban sale, transfer of assault weapons https://cjreview.com/2023/04/10/washington-primed-to-ban-sale-transfer-of-assault-weapons/ https://cjreview.com/2023/04/10/washington-primed-to-ban-sale-transfer-of-assault-weapons/#respond Mon, 10 Apr 2023 04:13:43 +0000 https://cjreview.com/?p=31 From: https://www.kgw.com/article/news/politics/washington-primed-ban-sale-transfer-of-assault-weapons/283-e3e6f2c7-0ebd-4bd6-90ef-50b7de6c0983 Recently, the “Assault Weapons Ban” passed both chambers of Washington lawmakers. This is unfortunate as it will surely cost taxpayers millions in defending an unconstitional law and, without question, the bill does nothing to solve deaths by firearms. It is, however, a great opportunity to point out the root cause of shootings and […]

The post Washington primed to ban sale, transfer of assault weapons appeared first on Criminal Justice Review.

]]>
From: https://www.kgw.com/article/news/politics/washington-primed-ban-sale-transfer-of-assault-weapons/283-e3e6f2c7-0ebd-4bd6-90ef-50b7de6c0983

Recently, the “Assault Weapons Ban” passed both chambers of Washington lawmakers. This is unfortunate as it will surely cost taxpayers millions in defending an unconstitional law and, without question, the bill does nothing to solve deaths by firearms.

It is, however, a great opportunity to point out the root cause of shootings and crime overall: Prosecutors refuse to prosecute. In Pierce, King, and Snohomish counties especially, prosecutors are refusing to charge felons in possesion of firearms, and possession of stolen firearms. If people really want to slow crime and prevent gun deaths, the best course of action is to demand your prosecutors do their jobs. Right now, they’re not, and crime stats show it.

The post Washington primed to ban sale, transfer of assault weapons appeared first on Criminal Justice Review.

]]>
https://cjreview.com/2023/04/10/washington-primed-to-ban-sale-transfer-of-assault-weapons/feed/ 0 31
Response to MSN’s How many more students and teachers must die before lawmakers act to stop gun violence? https://cjreview.com/2023/03/25/response-to-msns-how-many-more-students-and-teachers-must-die-before-lawmakers-act-to-stop-gun-violence/ https://cjreview.com/2023/03/25/response-to-msns-how-many-more-students-and-teachers-must-die-before-lawmakers-act-to-stop-gun-violence/#respond Sat, 25 Mar 2023 05:45:24 +0000 https://cjreview.com/?p=28 https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/opinion/how-many-more-students-and-teachers-must-die-before-lawmakers-act-to-stop-gun-violence/ar-AA191lCN?ocid=hpmsn&cvid=fa9fbdb5ddb44e649d1d239414d770d5&ei=56 Another passionate plea for “gun control” by someone who clearly desires safer communities. The latter is admirable, the former is sad. Why has this writer not written a piece advocating for prosecutors to actually hold criminals accountable? Why has this writer not written an expose on how jails and prisons are releasing criminals at […]

The post Response to MSN’s How many more students and teachers must die before lawmakers act to stop gun violence? appeared first on Criminal Justice Review.

]]>
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/opinion/how-many-more-students-and-teachers-must-die-before-lawmakers-act-to-stop-gun-violence/ar-AA191lCN?ocid=hpmsn&cvid=fa9fbdb5ddb44e649d1d239414d770d5&ei=56

Another passionate plea for “gun control” by someone who clearly desires safer communities. The latter is admirable, the former is sad. Why has this writer not written a piece advocating for prosecutors to actually hold criminals accountable? Why has this writer not written an expose on how jails and prisons are releasing criminals at record rates, and about how prosecutors are dropping charges–including countless gun charges–with no explanation other than they are “busy”?

As is often said, but never practiced: Enforce the laws currently on the books before creating new ones. Creating new laws simply makes more criminals. Not enforcing laws just makes more victims.

The post Response to MSN’s How many more students and teachers must die before lawmakers act to stop gun violence? appeared first on Criminal Justice Review.

]]>
https://cjreview.com/2023/03/25/response-to-msns-how-many-more-students-and-teachers-must-die-before-lawmakers-act-to-stop-gun-violence/feed/ 0 28
Burglary Suspects Continue Crime Wave https://cjreview.com/2023/03/17/burglary-suspects-continue-crime-wave/ https://cjreview.com/2023/03/17/burglary-suspects-continue-crime-wave/#respond Fri, 17 Mar 2023 15:13:35 +0000 https://cjreview.com/?p=22 https://www.q13fox.com/video/1194833 Q13Fox did a story detailing a group of burglars who continue to victimize residents in the Bellevue area. It is worth noting here that these people likely continue their crime wave because, under HB1054, police are unable to pursue them. Yes, to be clear, if these people burglarize your home and flee in a […]

The post Burglary Suspects Continue Crime Wave appeared first on Criminal Justice Review.

]]>
https://www.q13fox.com/video/1194833

Q13Fox did a story detailing a group of burglars who continue to victimize residents in the Bellevue area. It is worth noting here that these people likely continue their crime wave because, under HB1054, police are unable to pursue them.

Yes, to be clear, if these people burglarize your home and flee in a vehicle, even if police locate them, they cannot stop them if they run. This is the absurdity of anti-pursuit legislation. Further, some jails are still continuing COVID-era booking restrictions that prevent those arrested for burglary from even being booked into jail. And the research is clear: Booking restrictions correlate with massive increases in crime.

The post Burglary Suspects Continue Crime Wave appeared first on Criminal Justice Review.

]]>
https://cjreview.com/2023/03/17/burglary-suspects-continue-crime-wave/feed/ 0 22
Lawmaker Wants Funding Over Solutions https://cjreview.com/2023/03/14/lawmakers-wants-funding-over-solutions/ https://cjreview.com/2023/03/14/lawmakers-wants-funding-over-solutions/#respond Tue, 14 Mar 2023 04:14:21 +0000 https://cjreview.com/?p=20 Senator Lynda Wilson wants funding for “Auto Theft Prevention,” despite clear data showing that auto thefts have increased so dramatically because police cannot legally chase fleeing thieves. Most would think this laughable with the answers so clear, but alas, not in Washington.

The post Lawmaker Wants Funding Over Solutions appeared first on Criminal Justice Review.

]]>
https://www.king5.com/article/news/crime/car-thefts-washington/281-166aadc3-5dce-4918-8df1-1f7d4764db44

Senator Lynda Wilson wants funding for “Auto Theft Prevention,” despite clear data showing that auto thefts have increased so dramatically because police cannot legally chase fleeing thieves.

Most would think this laughable with the answers so clear, but alas, not in Washington.

The post Lawmaker Wants Funding Over Solutions appeared first on Criminal Justice Review.

]]>
https://cjreview.com/2023/03/14/lawmakers-wants-funding-over-solutions/feed/ 0 20